Premier League Match Centre explain why VAR did not overturn Andy Robertson’s foul on Tyler Dibling during Southampton vs Liverpool

The Premier League has issued an official statement addressing the contentious VAR decision that awarded Southampton a penalty during their match against Liverpool at St. Mary’s Stadium. The incident, which occurred late in the first half, has sparked widespread debate among fans and pundits, questioning the legitimacy of the call.

The controversial moment unfolded in the 40th minute when Liverpool’s Virgil van Dijk, attempting an ambitious back-heel pass, lost possession. Southampton’s Tyler Dibling seized the opportunity and was subsequently challenged by Andy Robertson near the penalty area. Referee Samuel Barrott deemed Robertson’s tackle a foul and awarded a penalty, a decision that surprised many given the unclear location of the contact.

VAR, led by Michael Oliver, conducted a thorough review but chose not to overturn the on-field decision. In its statement, the Premier League explained that VAR determined there was “no conclusive evidence” to prove the foul occurred outside the penalty area, thereby upholding the referee’s call.

The Match Centre elaborated on the decision, stating: “The referee’s call of penalty for the challenge by Robertson on Dibling is checked and confirmed by VAR, who deemed there was no conclusive evidence that the contact occurred outside the penalty area.”

Despite this clarification, the decision has ignited significant backlash on social media. Fans voiced their frustration, with one stating, “That is not a penalty. IT’S OUTSIDE THE BOX.” Another noted, “Robertson’s foot was on the line when the foul happened, it’s just inside.”

Others were more critical of VAR’s role, accusing it of bias and inconsistency. “We just watched Michael Oliver watch that dive and recommend a penalty. What a scam,” fumed one fan. Another wrote, “So now fouls outside the box count as penalties if you’re playing Liverpool?”

The incident has reignited concerns over VAR’s effectiveness and the consistency of Premier League officiating. While VAR was introduced to eliminate “clear and obvious errors,” critics argue it often causes more controversy and confusion. This latest decision adds to growing calls for greater transparency in the decision-making process and highlights the persistent challenges facing officiating in modern football.

For Liverpool, the penalty marked a pivotal moment in the match, further fueling the frustration of supporters who believe the call may have influenced the game’s outcome. As discussions surrounding the incident continue, the controversy serves as another example of the scrutiny VAR and Premier League referees face in high-stakes matches.