“I think I will win the Ballon D’or one day. I was happy when they sacked Erik ten Hag. He was not playing me the right way. But I will show the fans that I am on our next match under Rúben Amorim. He is my type of coach.”-BREAKING NEWS: Antony promises Manchester United fans that he will be back to scoring under Rúben Amorim and why he has been under-performing.

Antony’s Time at Manchester United: A Journey of Hopes, Challenges, and Uncertainty

When Antony marked his Manchester United debut with a goal just 35 minutes into a 3-1 win over Arsenal, it seemed Erik ten Hag’s insistence on signing him from Ajax for €95 million (plus €5 million in add-ons) was vindicated. The Brazilian’s dynamic start raised expectations, particularly as fans hoped he would solve United’s long-standing issues on the flanks. Yet, two years later, his career at Old Trafford has been marred by inconsistency and mounting doubts about his future.

—

A Promising Start Fades Away

Antony’s early performances suggested United had secured a star. He netted three goals in his first six appearances, including strikes against Manchester City and Everton, creating optimism about his potential impact. However, the spark faded quickly. Across two seasons, Antony has only scored nine goals in 81 games, a disappointing return for a player with such a high price tag.

This season, his sole goal came from the penalty spot in a Carabao Cup rout against Barnsley. Fans initially dismissed his eight goals in the first season as part of his adaptation period, but his stagnation and one-dimensional style of play have since become glaring issues.

—

Controversial Move to United

Antony’s transfer from Ajax was fraught with controversy. In 2022, he refused to play for the Dutch side to force a move, citing a lack of focus and missing key matches. Ajax manager Alfred Schreuder criticized Antony’s approach, accusing him of prioritizing money over commitment. While Antony eventually secured his dream move to Manchester, the episode raised concerns about his temperament—concerns that have only grown during his struggles at United.

—

Tactical and Technical Limitations

At Ajax, Antony thrived under ten Hag’s system, but his Premier League performances have exposed significant flaws. His reliance on his left foot and predictable tendency to cut inside have made him easy to defend against. In a physically demanding and tactically advanced league, these limitations have hindered his effectiveness.

With Ruben Amorim now at the helm, Antony has an opportunity to redefine his role. Amorim’s adaptable tactical style may challenge Antony to diversify his game, but failure to rise to the occasion could see him fall further out of favor.

—

Mental and Cultural Adaptation

Beyond the tactical issues, Antony’s struggles might also stem from mental and cultural challenges. The scrutiny and pressure at a club like Manchester United can be overwhelming, and Antony has often appeared to falter under the spotlight. His performances have drawn increasing criticism from fans and pundits, raising questions about his resilience.

—

A Critical Crossroads

Antony’s future at Old Trafford is uncertain. With fierce competition for attacking positions and Amorim likely to shake up the squad, Antony must improve quickly to secure his place. Players like Marcus Rashford and Luke Shaw have rebounded from poor form at United, showing that redemption is possible. Antony, too, could rewrite his narrative, but only if he embraces change and overcomes his limitations.

—

Lessons from Antony’s Transfer

Antony’s €100 million transfer has highlighted the pitfalls of inflated expectations and questionable recruitment strategies. His struggles serve as a reminder of the need for alignment between signings, tactical fit, and long-term planning. For United, it’s a lesson in avoiding overpaying for potential without clear evidence of readiness for the Premier League’s demands.

—

The Road to Redemption

For Antony to succeed, he must:

1. Expand His Skill Set: Improve his weaker foot, add unpredictability to his play, and sharpen his decision-making.

2. Seize Opportunities: Make the most of Amorim’s tactical adjustments to showcase his adaptability.

3. Build Resilience: Silence critics by proving his mental strength and ability to handle pressure.

Whether Antony’s United story ends in revival or departure, his journey will remain a pivotal chapter in the club’s ongoing rebuild. The next few months will determine if he can fulfill his potential or if a move away becomes inevitable.